Cap rates sit about 160 bps over the 10-year. Here's what that means for Charlotte retail.
Most pro formas on my desk this month were built for a world that ended in September. Since Sept. 10, the 10-year Treasury has sat near or above 5%. If your exit cap hasn't moved since, you're not underwriting a deal. You're underwriting a hope.
The big number: 160 bps
That's roughly how far the average commercial real estate cap rate sits above the 10-year, per CBRE Research. The long-run average is about 325. Half the normal cushion, thinnest on record.
CBRE expects cap rates to rise at least 40 to 60 bps, which implies average values down 6% to 10%. You can argue about the size. You can't argue about the direction.
What it means for Charlotte retail
CBRE expects less pressure on prime retail. The catch is "prime." In year five, the buyer decides whether your strip center or urban storefront counts.
Charlotte hasn't felt the squeeze yet. That's the point. Average retail caps here fell for a seventh straight quarter to 6.87%, pricing hit a record $263/SF, and $1.7B traded over the past 12 months, per Matthews.
Exhibit A: Specialty Shops SouthPark sold in July for $60M, about $919/SF, fully leased. It traded for $40.2M in 2023. A fully-leased trophy center earns a tight cap.
Exhibit B: Queen City Quarter, the old Epicentre on Trade Street, just sold for $27.5M. That's 71% below the $95M Deutsche Bank bid at its 2022 foreclosure, and 79% below the $130.5M CIM paid in 2014. It defaulted on an $85M loan in 2021 at about 35% occupied.
That's not a 6-10% cap-rate markdown. It's what happens when the loan comes due on a building the market stopped believing in. Lenders don't refinance hope.
The cap starts lying when you underwrite a short-lease, rolling-guaranty restaurant building like it's Exhibit A.
Three moves
1. Build the exit cap from the spread, not the comp. Pick a 10-year for your exit year, add a spread you can defend, then add at least 10 bps per year of hold. Comps tell you where the market was.
2. Run the boring scenario. Run the one where nothing bad happens: the 10-year stays near 5%, rents grow normally, spreads drift halfway back. If the deal doesn't clear there, it doesn't clear.
3. Underwrite the refi before the sale. A wave of loans comes due in 2027. Size any year-two or year-three refi at today's rates and coverage tests. The refi, not the sale, is where deals break.
What to do this week
Open every deal and every asset with a 2027 or 2028 maturity. Hold the 10-year at 5% through exit and set your exit cap at going-in plus 10 bps per year of hold. What breaks is a repricing conversation or a pass.
Then do the opposite exercise. Find the sellers whose models just broke. That's where the 2027 buying opportunities are coming from.
Forward this to the partner who still has a year-five exit at today's cap.
Your turn
What exit cap are you using right now?